New theory in Lion Air disaster

Geoffrey Thomas

By Geoffrey Thomas Tue Oct 30, 2018

Australian aircraft engineers suggest a new theory on the Lion Air disaster saying that the Boeing 737 MAX suffered rear elevator problems on its previous flight According to the engineers, the aircraft's tech log shows a record of a problem with "elevator feel and control" on the last flight the day before the tragedy that claimed 189. Any serious issue with the rear elevator would account for the sudden high-speed crash into the sea with speeds reaching 560km/h. What is also known is that the Lion Air 737 MAX also had control problems relating to erratic speed and altitude data the day before, similar to those seen just after the fatal flight took off. According to Aviation-Safety.net, ADS-B (transmitted from the aircraft) data of the flight, captured by Flightradar24 and FlightAware, showed erratic values. The aircraft made a climbing left-hand turn after takeoff. Shortly after passing the ADS-B reported altitude of 2100 feet, data points briefly show a lower altitude of around 1475 feet," the website reported. "Altitude data sent via ADS-B continue to show an erratic pattern, varying roughly between 4500 and 5350 feet, The values then rapidly decline until contact is lost at 06:32 hours." Aviation-Safety.net said that "the previous flight of the accident aircraft, JT043 from Denpasar, showed similar erratic values in altitude and airspeed after takeoff. After 8 minutes the values stabilized." A log entry cited by AirlineRatings.com shows "airspeed unreliable and alt disagree shown after take off. It adds that the Captain's instrument was unreliable and handover control to FO." Lion Air has confirmed that the aircraft had a "technical problem" on the previous flight, "which had been resolved according to the procedure.” The copy of the tech log that is circulating on media apparently shows that the Pitot Tube and Static Port, which provide airspeed and altitude data to the cockpit instruments and computers, were examined and checked. Put simply a pitot-static system is a system of pressure-sensitive instruments that are used in aviation to determine an aircraft's airspeed, altitude, and altitude trend.    

Have questions or want to share your thoughts?

Comments

No comments yet, be the first to write one.

Latest news and reviews

View more
NTSB Final Report: causes of the midair collision at Reagan National Airport
Airline News

NTSB Final Report: causes of the midair collision at Reagan National Airport

Feb 19, 2026

Josh Wood
This Canadian airline flies 49-year-old aircraft: we tell you why
Airline News

This Canadian airline flies 49-year-old aircraft: we tell you why

Feb 19, 2026

Josh Wood
LATAM 777’s high-stakes rejected takeoff in São Paulo prompts an investigation
Airline News

LATAM 777’s high-stakes rejected takeoff in São Paulo prompts an investigation

Feb 18, 2026

Josh Wood
Why Emirates built its airline around two aircraft - and why that’s changing
Airline News

Why Emirates built its airline around two aircraft - and why that’s changing

Feb 13, 2026

Nicholas Ling

Featured articles

View more
This review proves that low cost carriers aren't always cheaper: AirAsia X vs Malaysia Airlines long haul
Airline News

This review proves that low cost carriers aren't always cheaper: AirAsia X vs Malaysia Airlines long haul

Feb 12, 2026

Airline Ratings
NTSB Final Report: causes of the midair collision at Reagan National Airport
Airline News

NTSB Final Report: causes of the midair collision at Reagan National Airport

Feb 19, 2026

Josh Wood
AirAsia X low cost flights to London are back!
Airline News

AirAsia X low cost flights to London are back!

Feb 12, 2026

Josh Wood
LATAM 777’s high-stakes rejected takeoff in São Paulo prompts an investigation
Airline News

LATAM 777’s high-stakes rejected takeoff in São Paulo prompts an investigation

Feb 18, 2026

Josh Wood