Book Flights
 

Weekly Roundup – January 13th, 2020

777X
Boeing 777X being prepared for first flight. Credit Matt Cawby

Here are our 4 most popular articles from the past week.


Boeing 777X out of paint shop being prepared for first flight

777X
Boeing 777X being prepared for first flight. Credit Matt Cawby

Boeing’s 777X, WH001, is out of paint shop and being prepared for the first flight, which is expected this month.

READ ARTICLE


British Airways hits new low in Heathrow T5 lounges

British Airways T5 lounge low
Truly, the food was appalling, even for BA’s low lounge standards. Photo: John Walton

Looking back over my 2019 business class passenger experience, the worst gift this year was the discovery that British Airways flights to my home airport of Lyon were departing from London Heathrow’s Terminal 5 instead of Terminal 3.

READ ARTICLE


 Top Twenty Safest Airlines for 2020

Safest Airlines
Credit Mark Garfinkel

AirlineRatings.com, the world’s only airline safety and product rating website, has announced its Top Twenty Safest Airlines 2020 from the 405 different airlines it monitors.

READ ARTICLE


Dramatic video of flying through Australia’s devastating wildfires

wildfires

Dramatic video of flying through Australia’s devastating wildfires as been released by the Australian Defence Forces.

READ ARTICLE


Volcanic ash causes flight suspensions in Manila

volcanic
Volcanic ash spews out of Taal volcano. Photo: Exec8/Wikicommons Media.

Flights were suspended to Manila’s Ninoy Aquino International Airport Sunday night as a volcanic eruption south of the city sent an ash plume up to nine miles (14kms) into the air.

Airlines canceled hundreds of international and domestic flights Monday as a result of the eruption at Mt Taal but tweets by Philippine Airlines and Cebu Pacific suggested authorities were looking at a resumption of service during the day.

Cebu said it was conducting safety checks of its aircraft before resuming operations from 11 am local time.

READ: Angry Iranians protest missile attack on Ukrainian jet.

PAL also suggested the suspension could be lifted but said it was working in close coordination with airport and aviation authorities monitoring the ash cloud situation in case there was a need to extend the closure.

“Should the closure be extended, we may have to cancel or delay additional flights to or from Manila,’’ it added.

Flightradar24 tweeted early afternoon Philippines time that flights were operating as the cloud moved away from the airport.

However, it said there was still “a high level of flight disruption and a reduced operating schedule with nearly 400 flights canceled today”.

Taal Volcano, about 37 miles south of Manila on the island of Luzon, is one of the country’s most active and its eruption Sunday prompted the evacuation of three towns.

The Philippine Institute of Volcanology and Seismology said in an 8 am bulletin that the volcano had “entered a period of intense unrest”  beginning with steam-driven activity in several points inside the main crater on January 12.

It said a level 4 alert remained in effect for the volcano and a hazardous explosive eruption is possible within hours to days.

The center recommended the evacuation of Taal Volcano Island “and areas at high risk to pyroclastic density currents and volcanic tsunami within a 14-kilometer radius from Taal’s main crater.

“ Areas in the general north of Taal Volcano are advised to guard against the effects of heavy and prolonged ashfall,’’ it said.

“Civil aviation authorities must advise aircraft to avoid the airspace around Taal Volcano as airborne ash and ballistic fragments from the eruption column pose hazards to aircraft. “

 

Rolls-Royce robots help build greener jet engines

Rolls-Royce Bristol composite
The composite technology hub in Bristol will develop light-weight fan cases and blades. Photo: Rolls-Royce.

A new hi-tech Rolls-Royce facility in the UK aims to develop composite fan blades and fan cases aimed at significantly reducing the weight of jet engines.

The composite technology hub in Bristol will from January work on fan blades and cases for Rolls’ UltraFan engine designed to be 25 percent more efficient than company’s first-generation Trent engines.

The UltraFan has been hailed as the British manufacturer’s biggest step in engine architecture in half a century and is expected to power aircraft from the mid-2020s.

READ: MH370 families lose US court appeal.

The use of carbon composites to reduce engine weight equates to less fuel used and Rolls-Royce estimates a fan system made of the material can save almost 700kg per aircraft, or the equivalent of seven passengers and their luggage.

Rolls-Royce composite UltraFan
The new facility uses state-of-the-art automation. Photo: Rolls-Royce.

Rolls says the composite system for the new engine is taking shape and its different parts have completed aerodynamic performance, bird-strike, containment and water ingestion tests as well as ground and flight testing.

The fan blades are made from hundreds of layers of carbon-fiber materials prefilled with a tough resin and then heated under pressure. Each blade is finished with a thin titanium leading edge to battle erosion, foreign objects and bird strikes.

The new Bristol hub is designed to take composite manufacturing to the next level and means 150 jobs for the British city.

This includes the transfer of an existing manufacturing technology facility from the Isle of Wight along with about 30 employees.

And like the engine parts it produces, the facility is designed to reduce emissions and consumption with the latest low-energy, very low emissions processes with state-of-the-art robotics.

Watch a short video:

This allows it to maximize the use of raw materials while reducing waste as Rolls-Royce moves towards its target of zero emissions by 2030.

“This incredible new facility exemplifies our commitment to creating cleaner, more efficient forms of power,’’ said Rolls-Royce director aerospace technology and future programs Alan Newby.

“Our highly-skilled employees will use the latest technology, materials and manufacturing techniques to develop components that will contribute to lighter, quieter, more powerful jet engines with fewer emissions.”

Jetstar ground workers extend strike moratorium

engine
Photo: Jetstar

Jetstar baggage handlers and other ground workers have extended a moratorium on industrial action until January 29 after management agreed to resume negotiations over pay and conditions.

The ground workers took action twice in December as part of the wage push but agreed not to strike during the busy Christmas period.

The latest moratorium extends to the end of the traditional Australian summer break, which has already been disrupted for thousands of people by the national bushfire crisis.

READ: Airlines join wave of support for Aussie bushfire victims.

Jetstar announced in December it would reduce January capacity by 10 percent after unions representing pilots and groundworkers threatened continued industrial after Christmas-New year if their claims were not met.

But the Transport Workers’ Union said Jetstar management had agreed to meet with baggage handlers and ground staff on January 29 and the union had agreed to extend the moratorium as a sign of good faith.

TWU national secretary John Kaine said the workforce hoped Jetstar would undertake genuine negotiations and put forward proposals for consideration rather than just reject the union’s claims.

“Our claims are modest and they address safety and pay concerns,’’ Kain said. “Jetstar workers are the lowest paid in the Qantas group.

“Working conditions at Jetstar are tough with the company cutting the number of crew working to the point that safety is a problem.

“Crew want more rest breaks and more trained staff so they can do their jobs without risking injury.”

Pointing to Jetstar’s $4 billion in revenue and sizeable profits at Qantas, Kaine said workers had stuck with the company through tough times when Jetstar and Qantas insisted on pay freezes.

“Now they rightly expect to be treated fairly,’’ he said. “It’s time for the scales to be brought back into balance, and the company to meet their modest claims.”

The union representing many of the airline’s pilots are scheduled to meet management on January 28 in a separate dispute that also hinges on wages and conditions.

At this stage, the Australian Federation of Air Pilots has not notified the airline of any further protected industrial action but nor has it committed to a moratorium.

The union said it would assess the need for further action based on the progress of its enterprise agreement negotiations.

 

MH370 families lose US court appeal

MH370

The families of victims of missing Malaysia Airlines Flight MH370 crash have lost an appeal against a court ruling that lawsuits against the carrier, insurer Allianz and manufacturer Boeing do not belong in the US.

Lawyers for the families had appealed a 2018 ruling by a US District Court judge that 40 wrongful death and product liability lawsuits should be heard in Malaysia.

New Boeing CEO takes reins amid renewed public firestorm.

Malaysia Airlines Flight MH370 disappeared in March 2014 while flying from Kuala Lumpur to Beijing with 239 people on board and is believed to have crashed in the Southern Indian Ocean.

Extensive searches failed to find the wreckage and a final report on the disappearance was unable to determine a cause for the crash, although a widely held belief is that it was a murder-suicide involving the plane’s captain.

A three-judge panel with the US Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit found that a lower court did not abuse its discretion when it decided the case should be tried in Malaysia.

The ruling is a setback the families of more than 100 MH370 victims from countries such as Australia, China, India and Malaysia.

The district court found Malaysia’s public interest in hearing claims arising from the MH370 disappearance “far outweighed” that of the United States, even when it came to claims made against Boeing.

It also found that private interest factors tilted strongly in favor of trying the cases in Malaysia, given the overwhelming amount of evidence located in the South-East Asian nation and the “potentially insurmountable challenges” of making that evidence available in a US court.

Lawyers for the victims’ families had argued the court refused to afford any deference to the decision to sue in the US or to specify the precise degree of deference it had applied.

The Court of Appeals backed the lower court’s decision, describing it as a well-reasoned opinion and noting it had did not abuse its discretion that the balance of public and private interests weighed heavily in favor of trying the case in Malaysia.

It said the district court’s analysis reflected a careful consideration of the foreign families’ interests and a thoughtful balancing of the public and private interest factors” with respect to individuals.

The lower court also correctly recognized that Thomas Wood, a US citizen and resident suing on behalf of his dead brother, was entitled to the greatest degree of deference.

“We find no reversible error in the district court’s reasoning regarding the appropriate levels of deference afforded to appellants’ claims,’’ it said.

The issue was further complicated when Malaysia decided to renationalize the airline in late 2014 and restructure it by creating a new, separate entity, Malaysia Airlines Berhad (MAB).

The assets of Malaysia Airlines System were transferred to MAB and the original company was placed under administration. MAB did not assume the liabilities related to MH370.

Lawyers for the families were critical of the district court’s analysis of issues related to the MAS/MAB restructure and its immunity claims.

The panel found it was entirely proper for the district court to recognize that serious jurisdictional questions existed and weigh that as a factor in favor of dismissal.

Angry Iranians protest missile attack on Ukrainian jet

Missile 737 Iran Ukraine
Wreckage from the downed 737. Photo: Office of the Ukrainian president.

Iranians took the streets over the weekend to protest their government’s handling of a missile strike that brought down a Ukrainian Boeing 737 near Tehran last week.

The protestors demanded the country’s supreme leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, step down in the wake of the admission by the Iranian military that it was responsible for a ground to air missile that caused the passenger jet to crash and explode with 176 on board.

The military made the admission it had downed the Ukraine International Airlines jet “unintentionally, due to human error” after denying for several days that the accident was due to a missile strike.

READ: Iran admits to shooting down Ukrainian 737.

It claimed that the Ukraine International Airlines jet moved too close to a sensitive military base at a time tensions were high because of the US assassination of General Qassem Soleimani.

The altitude and direction of the flight presented like a hostile aircraft, it said.

However, an analysis by AirlineRatings editor-in-chief Geoffrey Thomas indicated the plane was following a similar flight path to other jets that had taken off from Tehran’s Imam Khomeini International Airport that day.

Many of the passengers on the plane were Iranians and crowds in Tehran expressed anger at the way Iran’s leaders had handled the crisis.

The commander of the Aerospace Force of the Revolutionary Guard, Brig. Gen. Amir Ali Hajizadeh, said in a televised statement that the missile strike was the result of a rash decision by a junior officer.

“When I became sure that the news was true,” The Wall Street Journal quoted Hajizadeh as saying. “I wished for death.

“All other organizations including the airport and civil aviation did their job correctly. All the blame is on us.”

Canada had 57 citizens on the plane – a number reduced by Canadian officials from an earlier estimate of 63 -and has sent a crash team to take part in the investigation alongside counterparts from Ukraine and Iran.

The US National Transportation Safety Board has also designated a representative to the probe.

Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau told a press conference on Saturday that Canada expected a full and complete investigation into the tragedy.

“We expect the full cooperation of the Iranians,’’ he said.

Trudeau said the Iranian admission was an important first step towards providing answers but noted that many questions remained to be answered.

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky said his country was seeking justice and expected a full and open investigation.

This included bringing those responsible to justice, the return of victims’ bodies and compensation, he said.

Some airlines have suspended operations to Tehran and the US Federal Aviation Administration has banned flights by US carriers over Iraq, Iran and Gulf waters.

New Boeing CEO takes reins amid renewed public firestorm

southwest
Southwest Airlines 737 MAX aircraft at Victorville, California. Image: KCAL9.

If  2019 was an “annus horribilis” for US aerospace giant Boeing, the start to 2020 hasn’t been much better in the run-up to new chief executive David Calhoun officially taking the reins on January 13.

Calhoun, 62, will have his work cut out to earn the $US28 million CBS News estimates he can potentially take home in 2020 as he moves to repair relationships with regulators and customers and focus on getting the 737 MAX back in the air.

In the last week alone, news emerged that the US Federal Aviation Authority has proposed fining Boeing $5.4 million over potentially defective wing parts on its 737 MAX aircraft, its outgoing CE0 made global headlines thanks to a massive payout of at least $US62 million and series of stunning internal messages left its credibility seriously tarnished.

One of its planes was shot down by the Iranian military, a major supplier announced massive layoffs due to the MAX crisis and the company is still grappling with the European Commission review of its deal to take a major stake in Embraer.

READ: Iran admits to shooting down Ukrainian 737.

Boeing is no longer in the spotlight for the downing last week of the Ukrainian 737 after the Iranian admission its Revolutionary Guard shot down the jet in what it says was a mistake.

A European Commission review that delayed the Embraer deal is also underway again after a two-month hiatus with a new decision deadline of April 30.

But that’s about as good as the recent news has been for the embattled plane-maker.

The $US5.4 million fine for issues involving slat tracks on the leading edge of a wing is on top of a $US3.9 million fine the US regulator proposed last month for similar problems on older 737NG jets.

The manufacturing problem hasn’t caused an issue with aircraft but the FAA says Boeing failed to adequately oversee its suppliers to ensure they complied with its safety assurance system and then knowingly submitted aircraft for FAA approval when it knew they had failed strength tests.

The company said it would ensure that all inspections and necessary part replacements were performed on the MAX aircraft before return service.

The eyebrow-raising payout to ousted CEO Dennis Muilenburg does not include any severance pay or a 2019 annual bonus. He also forfeited stock worth $US14.6 million.

However, the value of stock and pension entitlements to which he is contractually entitled totals $62.2 million at a time major supplier Spirit AeroSystems announced it was laying off 2,800 employees because of ongoing uncertainty about when the MAX will resume service.

Boeing has said it does not at this stage expect to furlough staff but it is this month suspending production of the 737 MAX and there is still no publicly available date for the grounded fleet to resume service.

The aircraft has been grounded since March 2019 after new flight control software was linked to fatal crashes at Indonesia’s Lion Air and Ethiopian Airlines. The two crashes killed a combined 346 people.

Getting the MAX back in the skies will be Calhoun’s top priority but the job of convincing the public everything is safe and above board has not been made easier by pages of damaging internal messages released last week.

The messages, seen by AirlineRatings, have stunned the industry with their cavalier attitude to safety and the regulatory process as well as their disdain for airlines.

The messages go back as far as 2013 but may relate to the development of 737 MAX flight simulators.

They reveal a campaign by some elements in the company to prevent regulators and airlines introducing simulator training for MAX pilots.

This included dissuading what appears to be an unnamed Jakarta-based airline that its pilots needed additional training.

The emails ridiculed regulators as well as fellow Boeing employees with one email noting that the MAX was “designed by clowns, who in turn are supervised by monkeys”.

There is talk of “Jedi mind tricking” various parties.

The chief technical pilot for the MAX talks about being under pressure to prevent regulators from requiring simulator training.

“I want to stress the importance of holding firm that there will not be any type of simulator training required to transition from NG to MAX,’’ he says. “Boeing will not allow that to happen. We’ll go face to face with any regulator who tries to make that a requirement.”

Boeing recently surprised many by dropping its opposition to simulator training for the MAX ahead of the return to service.

There are also further suggestions that employees may have concealed problems with the MAX  Flight simulators during FAA certification and in one exchange an employee says he would not put his family on a “MAX simulator trained aircraft”.

“I still haven’t been forgiven by God for the covering up I did last year,’’ another message says.

In releasing the messages, Boeing condemned the language used and said a review of MAX simulators concluded they were functioning correctly.

READ: Boeing confident on MAX simulators despite internal messages.

However, they have provided ammunition for US lawmakers investigating the MAX crashes and Boeing’s relationship with the FAA.

“They paint a deeply disturbing picture of the lengths Boeing was apparently willing to go to in order to evade scrutiny from regulators, flight crews, and the flying public, even as its own employees were sounding alarms internally,’’  said House Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure chair Peter DeFazio.

The FAA said in a statement its experts have determined that nothing in the documents pointed to any safety risks that had not identified as part of the MAX review process but described the tone and content of some messages as “disappointing”.

“The FAA maintains a rigorous process for qualifying flight simulators,’’ it said.

“Upon reviewing the records for the specific simulator mentioned in the documents, the agency determined that piece of equipment has been evaluated and qualified three times in the last six months. Any potential safety deficiencies identified in the documents have been addressed.”

 

Serious flaws in Iran’s claims on flight PS 752

Iran missile strike 737
The wreckage from the 737. Photo: ISNA

Iran’s explanation for the tragic loss of Flight PS 752, the Ukrainian Boeing 737 which was shot down with 176 onboard, is seriously flawed.

The Iranian authorities have claimed that the 737 had turned toward a military base, yet it was just following a standard departure route called “Parot 3G” which requires a slight right turn after take-off.

The flight path of the previous PS752 flights almost always followed the same flight path, while aircraft leaving Tehran to the north since the fatal flight, are also using the departure route.

AirlineRatings.com on CNN:

READ: Boeing’s 777X being prepared for first flight 

Here are three of those previous flights for PS 752 in the days before the fatal flight from Flightradar24:

And on the morning of the tragedy Turkish Airlines flight TK873 departed at 5.07 am – just over one hour earlier – and used the identical flight path.

Here is the flight path of TK873:

There were about five flights in the hour before the Ukraine International Airlines 737 took off.

In a statement, the nation’s armed forces said it targeted the passenger plane unintentionally. It attributed the crash to radar activity and fear of US action.
“The Islamic Republic of Iran deeply regrets this disastrous mistake. My thoughts and prayers go to all the mourning families,” Iranian President Hassan Rouhani said.
A statement Iranian armed forces headquarters said: “The aircraft came close to a sensitive IRGC military centre at an altitude and flight condition that resembled hostile targeting. Under these circumstances, the aircraft was unintentionally hit, which unfortunately resulted in the death of the many Iranian and foreign nationals.”
Iranian Foreign Minister Javad Zarif tweeted; “Human error at time of crisis caused by US adventurism led to disaster.”
The shooting down of PS752 is just one of many.
Since 1978 there have been 21 confirmed commercial planes hit by surface-to-air missiles, claiming 1237 lives. Adding to the misery are the six commercial flights downed by air-to-air missiles, which have taken 415 lives. Most of these fatalities have occurred in Africa, the Middle East and former Soviet Union countries.

Iran admits to shooting down Ukrainian 737

Ukrainian 737
A Ukraine International Airlines Boeing 737-800. Photo: tjdamstadt/Wikimedia Commons.

Iran has admitted to shooting down a Ukrainian 737 near Tehran this week, killing 176 passengers and crew.

According to a CNN report, the general staff of Iran armed forces admitted a Ukrainian plane that crashed on Wednesday was brought down due to human error. Iran targeted the passenger plane unintentionally, Iran’s Press TV reported.

Images shown yesterday of the crash site showed part of a missile amongst the debris.

The incident happened minutes after the Ukraine International Airlines 737 heading to Kiev had taken off from Tehran’s Imam Khomeini airport and came amid heightened tensions between the US and Iran over the assassination of Iranian commander Qassem Soleimania.

Iran had earlier launched missile attacks on two bases in Iraq staffed by US personnel.

A statement run by Iranian state media Saturday said the plane was mistaken for a hostile target after it turned towards a sensitive Revolutionary Guard military center.

It said the military was at its highest level of readiness due to heightened tensions with the US.

“In such a condition, because of human error and in a(n) unintentional way, the flight was hit,” the statement said, adding that Iran would upgrade its systems to prevent a similar accident.

Iran Foriegn Minister Javad Zarif tweeted that the tragedy was the result of human error at a time of crisis “caused by US adventurism”.

“Our profound regrets, apologies and condolences to our people, to the families of all victims, and to other affected nations,” he said.

Iran initially denied that the plane had been shot down and its decision to come clean came after Western leaders revealed intelligence that indicated a missile strike.

The push was spearheaded by  Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau who announced Thursday (North American time) there was evidence the Boeing 737 was shot down by a  ground-to-air missile.

Canada had 63 citizens among the 176 who died when the jet plummeted to the ground,  apparently on fire, and exploded.

READ: More than 170 dead as Boeing 737 crashes in Tehran.

Trudeau said Canada had intelligence from multiple sources ” including our allies and our own intelligence”.

He would not detail the evidence but said it was enough to allow him to share the suggestion with the Canadian people.

“The evidence indicates that the plane was shot down by an Iranian surface-to-air missile,” Trudeau told a Press conference.

“This may well have been unintentional.

“This new information reinforces the need for a thorough investigation into this matter.

“Canada is working with its allies to ensure that a thorough and credible investigation is conducted to determine the causes of this fatal crash.

CBS News said sources had told it a satellite detected the infrared signature of two missile launches followed by a “blip” of an explosion.

Newsweek quoted US officials and an Iraqi source as saying the plane was hit by a Russian-made Tor missile.

UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson and Australian Prime Minister Scott Morrison also backed the ground-to-air missile scenario.

Iran has now invited Boeing and the US National Transportation Safety Board to join the investigation and the NTSB has confirmed it has designated a representative.

Boeing 777X out of paint shop being prepared for first flight

777X
Boeing 777X being prepared for first flight. Credit Matt Cawby

Boeing’s 777X, WH001, is out of paint shop and being prepared for the first flight, which is expected this month.

According to @mattcawby the 777X left the paint hangar on January 7 and was moved to the fuel dock for primary flight control system testing.

He suggests that taxi tests will start “very soon.”

LOVE the Swiss Alps and the DC-3? You will love this video!

The 777X WH001 is for electromagnetic compatibility antenna scan testing on January 11.

Upgraded GE engines were installed in December.

The upgrade incorporates improvements to fix durability problems that were unearthed late in the engine test program last summer.

The issue, centred on the stator vanes in the compressor and forced Boeing to delay the start of flight tests of the 777-9 from July 2019 to early 2020.

Deliveries of the Boeing 777X are delayed till early 2021.

Boeieng 777X

The aircraft combines the best features of the current 777 with a longer and wider internal fuselage, new engine and the composite wing design from the Boeing 787.

It also features 20 per cent larger windows and has lower pressurization altitude to reduce jet lag.

WATCH: Amazing thermal video of Boeing 757 landing

The 777-9X seats more than 400 passengers, depending on an airline’s configuration choices.

With a range of more than 8,200 nautical miles (15,185 km), the aircraft will have the lowest operating cost per seat of any commercial aircraft says, Boeing.

The second member of the family, the 777-8X, will be the most flexible jet in the world claims Boeing. The aircraft will seat 350 passengers and offer a range capability of more than 9,300 nautical miles (17,220 km).

The driving force behind the aircraft is Emirates President Sir Tim Clark, whose airline is the lead buyer with an order for 126. This order was originally 150, however at the Dubai Air Show in November the airline exercised substitution rights and converted 24 Boeing 777X aircraft into 30 787-9s.

With the conversion, Emirates remains the world’s biggest 777X customer with 126 aircraft on order and the largest 777 operator with 155 aircraft today.

777X

 

THE RATINGS YOU NEED!

AIRLINE SAFETY RATINGS
The only place in the world to get ALL Airline Safety Ratings in one place! The ONLY airline rating that includes Safety, Product and COVID-19 safety ratings! Visit our Ratings Now!

2024 Airline Excellence Awards

View our special section announcing the 2024 Airline Excellence Awards!

AIRLINERATINGS NEWSLETTER

Subscribe to have AirlineRatings.com Newsletter delivered to your inbox!

STAY CONNECTED

61,936FansLike
2,336FollowersFollow
4,714FollowersFollow
681FollowersFollow
Cookie settings