Seat crunch court ruling could affect the way we fly.

Jerome Greer Chandler

By Jerome Greer Chandler Sun Aug 6, 2017

In a move that could have major implications for the way we fly, a US court has ordered the Federal Aviation Administration to look at minimum standards for seat pitch and width on commercial airliners. The United States Court of Appeals For the District of Columbia, considered by some to be the second most influential court in the land,  was responding to a petition by lobby group Flyers Rights. The court said the consumer group contended narrower seats and closer spacing were “endangering the safety, health and comfort of airline passengers.” Judge Patricia Ann Willett said the FAA asserted that seat spacing did not affect the safety or speed of passenger evacuations. “To support that conclusion, the Administration pointed to (at best) off-point studies and undisclosed tests using unknown parameters,” she said. In a written statement after the court’s ruling, the FAA said it did consider seat pitch (essentially leg room) in testing and assessing the safe evacuation of commercial passengers aircraft. “We are studying the ruling carefully and any potential actions we may take to address the court’s findings,” it said. The fundamental rule the FAA uses before certifying an aircraft can carry passengers is the ability to evacuate all passengers within 90 seconds, in low visibility with half the exits blocked. Flyers Rights said seat scrunch could not only affect evacuation time but threaten longer-haul passengers with DVT Deep Vein Thrombosis—blood clots.   AirlineRatings has written extensively over the years about the DVT threat. “This is the Case of the Incredible Shrinking Airline Seat,” wrote Judge Millett. “As many have no doubt noticed, aircraft seats and the spacing between them have been getting smaller and smaller, while American passengers have been growing in size.” Flyers Rights says seat width has shrunk from some 18.5 inches in the early part of the 21st Century to 17 inches in the middle of this decade. Meanwhile, seat pitch has gone from 35 inches to 31 inches and, in some planes, to 28 inches. At the same time,  it argued, Americans had become bigger. The court was notably pointed when it criticized FAA’s record- keeping when it comes to testing. Judge Millett wrote: “That type of vaporous record will not do—the Administrative Procedures Act requires reasoned decision making grounded in actual evidence.” US. airlines and their passengers will be waiting to see if and how FAA lifts those vapors in the coming months.

Have questions or want to share your thoughts?

Comments

No comments yet, be the first to write one.

Latest news and reviews

View more
Is easyJet making a bad decision?
Airline News

Is easyJet making a bad decision?

Jul 6, 2026

Josh Wood
Africa's safest airlines
Airline News

Africa's safest airlines

Jun 26, 2026

Josh Wood
Air Europa Business Class review
Airline Ratings review

Air Europa Business Class review

Jun 26, 2026

Josh Wood
The rise of STARLUX Airlines
Airline News

The rise of STARLUX Airlines

Jun 26, 2026

Airline Ratings

Featured articles

View more
Malaysia Airlines recognised as a Seven Star PLUS safety rated airline
Airline News

Malaysia Airlines recognised as a Seven Star PLUS safety rated airline

Jun 24, 2026

Airline Ratings
EVA Airways Business Class: Still impressive, but not cutting edge
Airline Ratings review

EVA Airways Business Class: Still impressive, but not cutting edge

Jun 25, 2026

Airline Ratings
Malaysia Airlines vs Singapore Airlines Economy: Whos the better choice  from Australia and beyond?
Airline News

Malaysia Airlines vs Singapore Airlines Economy: Whos the better choice from Australia and beyond?

Jun 11, 2026

Sharon Petersen
STARLUX vs Delta Airlines from Taipai to North America and beyond
Airline News

STARLUX vs Delta Airlines from Taipai to North America and beyond

Jun 19, 2026

Sharon Petersen